Let's move on.
The continued criticisms in both directions, however well intentioned, are no longer serving a constructive purpose and are in fact detracting from the current discussion at hand; that being the growing mainstream popularity of Gymnastic Strength Training™. The audience at T-nation has evinced a substantial interest in Gymnastic Strength Training™, rather than criticizing their interest let's simply make sure that they are learning good quality movements and progressions, correctly demonstrated by accomplished athletes when necessary, and getting the most out of their effort invested.
Yours in Fitness,
Coach Sommer