I don't believe in intentionally practising something incorrectly - i.e. something you continually get wrong and fail to perform properly. I've never known it to lead to improvements in anything - over any time scale - and I can't imagine that handstand work is unique in this respect.
Sometimes I can get 9 out of 10 kickup attempts (lunge style and variations thereof) into a balance, and sometimes it will be 0 out of 10. In a typical session it will be about a 40% success rate. I've been at this for quite a few years, actually, and I know I'm doing it wrong.
I feel that kicking up to a handstand tends to be a neglected skill on most forums and in most discussions - perhaps it tends to come naturally people? Not to me! Without a reliable kickup it becomes very frustrating and tiring, or simply impossible, to get enough time on your hands to work on cleaning up your line or anything else. Kicking up is also quite "stressful" - physically and, how can I put it, nervously? So they wear me down a lot each time I get one wrong.
I will try to get some videos of my attempts when I find somewhere larger than my bedroom to practice, when perhaps I could get some tailored advice. But the purpose of this thread is to collect some tips and tricks that you found useful when struggling with learning a reliable kickup to handstand. If indeed there ever was such a time.
I'll start with some that have helped me a great deal so far - yes, I was once much worse!
> Bring your legs up one at a time, and count them separately. One... two. Practice kicking up to a front/back split to train this.
> Go slowly at first, get all your hand placement and body position right - you don't have to do the whole thing at full speed right away. Do slow walk-throughs with slight hops at first.
Points like that, which are often completely overlooked, helped me tremendously. Would anyone like to share things that helped them get very reliable basic kickups? As usual, I'm particularly interested to hear from people who did once find this to be a problem (or those who have dealt with such people).
Thanks!