This forum is archived information and is no longer active.

HBP/PE2 form feedback

Started by George Traganidas 235308, November 20, 2016 · 13 Replies · 270 Views

Alessandro Mainente

Hi George, during the PE i prefer to see a more strong protraction and depression of the shoulder blades.

IN order to accurately review the IM I need a front view video.

George Traganidas 235308

Just to clarify, in the PE my shoulders should be more depressed during the whole motion and at the top position they should be more protracted?

I will record and new video of the mobility and I will upload shortly.

Thanks.

George Traganidas 235308

I include here a new video that shows the IM from the front. I have also tried to change my PE to protract and depress my shoulder blades more, as instructed.

https://drive.google.com/open?id=0B9SwWGTeydS9ZlhGYUNmOUlKdkE

Can you please provide me with more feedback?

George

Jeffrey Bittner

Hi George,

Your PE looks better. I would still like to see even more protraction at the top of each rep as Alessandro mentioned. The iM looks okay. Make sure that when your arm is by the ear your are pivoting the shoulder before bringing the weight down.

Alessandro Mainente

During the IM if we want to be more accurate there is imbalance between right and left. If we assume to have a wall near your shoulder then with the right shoulder you are not touching in, while with the left you are carrying to home a piece of wall ;).

Try to me as much symmetric as you can.

Greg White

Hi George,

On the PE I've found it helps to take a couple of seconds to get a strong protraction/depression when you first get into position, before starting the first rep. It helps to understand what the protraction / depression feels like during the reps.

George Traganidas 235308

Thanks @Alessandro Mainente for the feedback. I have noticed that my left shoulder has way less mobility that the right. I am working on it :)

Thanks @Greg White. I will give it a go.

Please forgive my ignorance, but why do we need so much protraction at the top? Where does this help? I have never heard of this before and I think that I was protracted enough. Apparently I need more :)

Greg White
15 hours ago, George Traganidas 235308 said:

Thanks @Alessandro Mainente for the feedback. I have noticed that my left shoulder has way less mobility that the right. I am working on it :)

Thanks @Greg White. I will give it a go.

Please forgive my ignorance, but why do we need so much protraction at the top? Where does this help? I have never heard of this before and I think that I was protracted enough. Apparently I need more :)

This might help answer the question: https://www.gymnasticbodies.com/all-about-scapular-positions/

In case you haevnt already I'd consider submitting form checks to make sure that you have enough protraction on your Scap Shrugs. If your Scap Shrugs aren't protracted enough it will make the Push Ups harder than necessary.

George Traganidas 235308

@Greg White thanks for the article. Now it makes a lot more sense. I am still at the start of the path and sometimes I find it helpful to know what is the end goal, because some of the fundamental moves do not makes sense unless you know what you are working towards.

I have already submitted a form video for Scap Shrugs.

Jeffrey Bittner

Hi George,

Nice improvement! Your PE is looking solid.

On you iM, I would still like to see more rotation in the shoulder as your arm is by your ear. This rotation is the 'pivoting' motion that I mentioned previously.

Matic Balantic

It's nice to see the effort you are putting in to improve your form, nice work! Btw, don't mess with the lady behind you :lol::P 

George Traganidas 235308

Have a Merry Christmas and a Happy New Year.

Thanks guys. I will get back at it.