Jeff,
I weigh and measure everything unless I have a day where I eat out at an "all you can eat" style place or just go totally off the rails for the day (logged on MyFitnessPal as LurkingFrog). Personally, I find it help me with compliance and gives me data points for later if I need to look for patterns, but I know it drives a lot of people nuts trying to do it.
I figure macros are likely coming soon to a step near me, so I was wondering if it was worth maintaining the habit since I've already integrated it into my cooking or if I should back off as overkill and just enjoy my eating.