My case might be a little unique, and at the same time it might not. I'm 20 years old, a sophomore in college, 6' 2" with an ape index of +4 (long arms), ~160 pounds (so around/just under 10% body fat). I've wanted to do gymnastics from a young age, and would have definitely done it had a facility been available to me earlier (I trained for a year in 3rd grade but then my family moved and I had to switch to rock climbing). My sports background is some competitive rock climbing (with a team), a little parkour, wrestling, track and 5 years competitive rowing (4 in high school, 1 in college).
I made a pretty tough decision to quit crew at the beginning of this year, since I've always wanted to try gymnastics and wanted to take the only chance that might turn up. So starting at the beginning of this year, I've been going to my college's club gymnastics practices (6 x 2.5 hrs / week), and sometimes staying late for conditioning/stretching/a bit of extra work during the cheerleading practices which follow the gymnastics practice. So on a really good week, I get around 18-20 hours a week in the gym; on average ones, it's closer to 12-15hrs.
I made a decision to compete this year on the NAIGC circuit with the club, mostly for the experience; however, I really want to see how much I can advance in gymnastics (I have a bit over 2 years until graduation, and hopefully more after that, assuming that I find a place to practice). Right now I train mostly floor & parallel bars, since having good basics on floor seems to be a prerequisite for most apparatus work, and parallel bars seemed to have a slightly easier learning curve than the other apparatus. I've been at this since September, and I can put together really basic (A-level skills) routines on both.
A lot of gymnastics movements seem to be linked, and there's a natural sort of "progression" from one step to the next - however, I've found that there are some keystone elements that are foundational for a well-rounded gymnast: a proper handstand, for example, a stalder roll and a strong back extension roll are examples that immediately come to mind. I'm following the Foundation 1 programming for strength and mobility, but I'm not sure what the best way to proceed in order to advance my skill proficiency at individual apparatuses: I have a fairly large chunk of time in the gym each week, but it seems like I don't get everything that I could out of it. Hence, the question:
Suppose you had a lot of time in the gym, were a beginner at most of the apparatuses, and wanted to compete the best routines that you could (level 9 if I'm extremely lucky) on all of the apparatuses in 2 and a half years (or at least try to - the journey is more important than the result). What is the best way to spend the time in the gym? Repetition of basics - swinging, pommel circles, basic tumbling over and over? Training basic routines or attempt to put skills together and show something? Focus on strengthening / stretching joints to possibly support an increase in the amount of skill work later on?
I'm curious to hear your opinions.
P.S. I posted a similar question to reddit.com/r/gymnastics, and was told that because of my height, I should have a stringent focus on execution of skills rather than difficulty per se, since it's easier to see form breaks. It was an insightful suggestion - I've gone back to work on the very basics with perfect form and consistency, and it's not as easy as it appears.
P.P.S. Oops, I meant to post this in the Getting Started forum. If a mod thinks this post belongs there instead, could you please move it? Thanks!